Film Review: Baby Done is delightful and real

Packed with New Zealand comedic talent, this character-driven story about impending parenthood is genuinely funny, writes Mel Campbell.

Zoe (Rose Matafeo) prides herself on being fearless and free-spirited. She works as an arborist alongside her boyfriend Tim (Matthew Lewis), and is gunning for the World Tree Climbing Championships in Vancouver. They promise each other they’ll never knuckle under like the friends they keep losing to dull normie parenthood.

As Tim, Zoe and Zoe’s pal Molly (Emily Barclay) endure yet another elaborate baby shower where everyone either has a baby, is having a baby, or is a baby, Zoe reiterates the stages of defeat: ‘Married, house, baby, done.’

So when Zoe learns she’s pregnant, she panics that her independent life is over. ‘I want to have a baby,’ she says – ‘I just don’t want to turn into a mum.’ While an overjoyed Tim embraces impending fatherhood, Zoe fights her pregnancy all the way to the delivery room in this delightful Kiwi comedy from husband-and-wife director Curtis Vowell and writer Sophie Henderson (Fantail).

Produced by Carthew Neal and Taika Waititi’s Piki Films, Baby Done is full of the dry situational humour and shaggy indie aesthetic that have come to characterise New Zealand comedies. Fans of the genre will spot familiar faces including Rachel House (Hunt for the Wilderpeople) as a school principal; Loren Taylor (Eagle vs Shark) as Zoe’s mum; Nic Sampson (Funny Girls) as a ‘preggophile’ Zoe encounters; and Madeleine Sami (The Breaker Upperers) as a no-nonsense midwife.

Henderson wrote the script during her own pregnancy, and it sings with little observational moments. I enjoyed Zoe’s shock when confronted by a toddler versus the way an eager-to-please Tim only makes a baby cry, plus Zoe’s extemporised, bitingly sarcastic ‘birth plan’, which pays off beautifully later in the film. But I especially loved the way Zoe and Tim repeatedly correct the platitude ‘best for baby’ to ‘best for the baby’. You can just tell this bugged the hell out of Henderson.

The film’s physical comedy set-pieces are enjoyably undignified: it features one of the most cringeworthy threesome scenes ever committed to film, plus the best pissing joke since Girls Trip. But even as Zoe and Tim clutch at the straws of hedonistic youth, this isn’t a raucous kidult comedy along the lines of Knocked Up, Baby Mama or Bad Neighbours.

Baby Done is full of the dry situational humour and shaggy indie aesthetic that have come to characterise New Zealand comedies.

Instead, it’s more like Juno or Obvious Child: a character-driven story about whether a relationship can survive the upheaval of pregnancy. As the film begins, Tim and Zoe are comfortable together – as complacent in their way as the parents they mock – but the pregnancy pushes them in different directions. Zoe’s reckless disregard for her physical limitations exasperates the earnest, careful Tim; meanwhile, Zoe feels trapped and manipulated by Tim’s pregnancy planning.

Read: Film Review: Brazen Hussies celebrates the living history of Australian feminism

Matafeo and Lewis have a lovely, low-key chemistry: they make Zoe and Tim seem like real people you’d want to have as friends. But former Harry Potter star Lewis never outshines popular stand-up comedian Matafeo, who effortlessly carries the film’s dramatic moments as well as its comic ones. Her facial expressions are so richly funny; in one of the best scenes, overwrought and crying, she struggles to pose for passport photos. Yet Matafeo also makes Zoe loveable in her darker moments, as she pushes back – sometimes literally – against the idea that a pregnant woman is just a vessel for a baby.

Zoe’s terror of being losing herself may be heightened for laughs, but it’s never treated as a delusion. Instead, it’s a completely reasonable response to a society that seeks to tie women down instead of celebrating how high they can climb. And what makes Baby Done so satisfying is that it doesn’t make Zoe abandon her dreams.

4 stars ★★★★

New Zealand, 2020, 91 mins
Director: Curtis Vowell
Writer: Sophie Henderson
Executive Producers: Carthew Neal, Taika Waititi
Producer: Morgan Waru
Rated: M
Australian Distributor: Madman
Release Date: 22 October 2020 (to be confirmed in Victoria)


4 out of 5 stars






Mel Campbell
About the Author
Mel Campbell is a freelance cultural critic and university lecturer who writes on film, TV, literature and media, with particular interests in history, costume, screen adaptations and futurism. Her first book was the nonfiction investigation Out of Shape: Debunking Myths about Fashion and Fit (2013), and she has co-written two romantic comedy novels with Anthony Morris: The Hot Guy (2017) and Nailed It (2019).